This is why the Madlanga Commission has closed its hearings to the public

The Madlanga Commission of Inquiry has temporarily adjourned its public proceedings and resumed behind closed doors, citing sensitive evidence tied to ongoing criminal investigations.

Justice Mbuyiseli Madlanga, who chairs the commission, confirmed on Thursday that proceedings will continue in camera today and tomorrow.

The public and media are expected to return next week once the sensitive evidence has been handled.

“This is the first time those implicated will hear of the information,” Madlanga told attendees before adjourning the session.

“Spokesperson Jeremy Michaels will provide further updates on next week’s programme.”

Media houses initially opposed the decision for private hearings, but later conceded after learning that the confidentiality is not to protect the witness’s identity—but to safeguard active police investigations.

Chief evidence leader, Advocate Matthew Chaskalson SC, clarified the rationale:“The subject matter of the evidence—not the identity of the witness—necessitates an in-camera session.

Public disclosure at this stage could compromise police investigations that are already at an advanced stage.”

Chaskelson emphasised that the commission’s work often overlaps with parallel police probes, making strategic confidentiality essential.

“We hope that, well before the commission concludes, these investigations will reach a stage where this evidence can be shared publicly. Once that happens, today's testimony will be made public.”

He added that while the decision was made with caution, it is crucial to maintain narrative coherence within the commission’s broader findings.

“It makes thematic sense to hear this evidence now—even if secrecy is temporarily necessary.”

Independent Newspapers, which had initially signaled an intention to challenge the closed-door ruling, have since withdrawn their opposition.

After consultations with the commission and evidence leaders, the media group expressed satisfaction with the ruling.

Importantly, Chaskalson noted that no additional witnesses will testify in private without a formal application.

“As per paragraph five of the commission’s ruling, any future in-camera sessions will be publicly announced at least 72 hours in advance.”

The commission is expected to resume public hearings next week, once the integrity of the current investigations is no longer at risk.

It is not clear who today’s witness but it is believed someone from the South African Police Service (SAPS).

kamogelo.moichela@iol.co.za

IOL Politics