Terry Motau's resignation request raises credibility concerns for Madlanga Commission

THE Madlanga Commission of Inquiry has yet to provide clarity on reports that one of its evidence leaders Advocate Terry Motau has indicated his intention to resign. 

Motau, the chief evidence leader, reportedly told the City Press that he has made a request to leave the commission but refused to share reasons about his departure as nothing has been finalised yet. 

According to the report, Motau was requested to reconsider his decision and has undertaken to give feedback soon. Motau on Sunday did not respond to messages and calls. Madlanga Commission spokesperson Jeremy Michaels was not available for comment as his phone was off. 

Political analyst Zakhele Ndlovu said although Motau's resignation from the commission will not derail its work, it may raise questions about its credibility.

Ndlovu added that this came as a shock as the commission is less than a month old, calling on Motau to provide reasons behind his decision.

“Without him (Motau) giving us the reason for quitting, it leaves us speculating. The commission is less than a month old and what could be the reason for his decision to quit. Some people think he could have been threatened. We may never know the truth,” he said.

President Cyril Ramaphosa, who demanded the first report within three months, established the commission in July to investigate serious allegations of criminal syndicates infiltrating and corrupting South Africa’s criminal justice system. The inquiry was triggered by public accusations made by KwaZulu-Natal Police Commissioner Lieutenant-General Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi.

Mkhwanazi alleged that criminal actors had penetrated law enforcement and interfered with investigations into high-profile political murders in KwaZulu-Natal. He also accused Police Minister Senzo Mchunu of improperly disbanding the Political Killings Task Team, potentially under corrupt influence.

Mkhwanazi claimed a police investigation in Gauteng had uncovered a drug cartel syndicate that involved and corrupted politicians, law enforcement officials, and members of the judiciary.

Mchunu has denied the claims.

Political analyst Professor Sipho Seepe, said the country should brace itself for delays, saying delays caused by resignations should be factored in any proper planning. 

“To that extent, there will be someone to replace him. We should brace ourselves for such hiccups,” Seepe said.

The MK Party suggested the reason for Motau’s possible departure 'could be interference, which might have a negative impact'. 

“He is now finding himself presiding over politically sensitive issues,” said spokesperson Nhlamulo Ndhlela.

He said that the party was also concerned that Motau’s departure could impact the process and the integrity of the commission.